Free Excel review template for IT and ERP managers, as of November 2026

Contractor Performance Review Template: Extend, Convert or Roll Off

Four reviews, five scored questions and one decision at the end, so the renewal date doesn’t make the call for you.

Free Excel file for a work email. Or read the whole template on this page.

Every review ends in one of three

  • Extend
  • Convert
  • Roll off
Engineering manager in a forest green top listens with a pen above a blank review form while a contract developer in a grey sweater makes a point with an open hand, two white mugs and one orange mug on the round table between them

Review a contractor at 30, 60 and 90 days and again before renewal, and end every review by picking one of three outcomes, extend, convert or roll off. KORE1 contractors can convert at no fee after 1,040 hours.

Last updated: November 19, 2026

Plenty of contractors get reviewed exactly once, in the last week of the assignment, in a hurry, because somebody in finance needs a signature on the renewal and the form has a box for it. That’s a bad way to decide anything.

Four short reviews fix it. One at 30 days, one at 60, one at 90 and one before the renewal, each with the same five questions and one answer at the end that you write down before anyone signs anything. Extend, convert or roll off. You’ll know which before the renewal date does it for you.

Coffee buyers don’t judge a cup while it’s hot. They score the same sample again as it cools, because a flaw is easier to taste once the heat is gone. A contractor’s first month is the hot cup, when everyone’s polite, the access is new and the first deliverable looks fine, and day 90 is the cool cup, which is when you find out what was hiding in it. Then the buyer does one of three things. Buys the lot, cups it again or passes. Same three answers here.

It’s the template I’d hand any manager who has never run a contractor, and it works the same for an ERP consultant or a developer, because the five questions don’t care what the contractor builds. It picks up where the contractor onboarding checklist leaves off. The contractors in it are the people KORE1 places on contract, including through its contract-to-hire staffing.

Download the Contractor Performance Review Template

One work email and the Excel file is yours. It has the same five questions and four reviews as the form below, with every blank shaded and the three rules built in.

  • The review form

    Five questions, four reviews, a 1 to 5 score in every cell. It averages each review and suggests extend, convert or roll off. You make the call.

  • The dates and the hours

    Enter the start and end dates and it sets the four review dates. Enter the hours to date and it shows how far the contractor is from 1,040.

  • The conversation log

    A page for what you said, what they said and what you agreed, so each review starts where the last one stopped.

Where should we send it?

    Work email, please. We use your details to respond to this request. See our privacy policy.

    When Should You Review a Contractor?

    Four times. Each review has one main question, and each one is a cooler cup than the last.

    • Day 30

      about 170 hours in

      Is the work started and the access sorted?

      The first month is setup. Score what you can see, and write down what you could not. A late laptop and a missing login are your misses, not theirs.

    • Day 60

      about 340 hours in

      Is the work good?

      This is the first review that counts. Quality and delivery have had time to show, and the first real bug has landed on somebody.

    • Day 90

      about 510 hours in

      Could someone else run it?

      Knowledge captured moves more than any other score between day 30 and day 90, and it hurts most when nobody checks it until the day the contractor is already packing up.

    • Before renewal

      two weeks before the end date

      Do you still need the seat?

      Hold it two weeks before the end date so the calendar does not make the call. The median KORE1 assignment ends at day 116, so for most contractors this is the day 100 review.

    A contractor on a 40-hour week reaches day 90 at about 510 hours. The median KORE1 contract assignment runs 116 days, or about 660 hours, so most contractors are gone long before they reach the 1,040 hour line, and that’s why the last review sits before the end date and not at the line. Plan for that.

    Short assignment? Skip day 60 and keep the other three. Long one? Add a review every 60 days after day 90. The questions stay the same, and so does the habit.

    Run each review in five steps

    1. Set the four dates on day one

      Put the day 30, day 60, day 90 and before-renewal dates in both calendars, with the contractor invited.

    2. Score the five questions

      Give each question a 1 to 5, and write one fact behind every score. No fact, no score.

    3. Show the contractor the scores

      Walk through the form together before you file it, and change any score the facts do not support.

    4. Make the call

      Pick extend, convert or roll off with the three rules, and note whether a seat exists after the project.

    5. Act within a week

      Tell your recruiter, set the next date, start the conversion or begin the hand-off.

    The template

    What Goes on a Contractor Performance Review Form?

    Five questions, scored 1 to 5 at every review. The sample is an ERP consultant, and each question has an ERP prompt and an IT one, so use whichever fits your seat.

    The template, filled in with a sample

    Contractor review form

    Contractor
    Name
    Role and start date
    Role, start date
    Reviewer
    Your name
    Hours to date
    Hours

    Score each question from 1 to 5

    • Beyond the ask
    • Ahead of plan
    • On plan
    • Behind plan
    • Not there
    Contractor review form with five questions scored at four reviews, with the average and the suggested call under each review
    QuestionDay 30Day 60Day 90Before renewal
    DeliveryDid the work land when you agreed it would?ERP The saved searches, the integration fix and the month-end report arrived on the dates in the plan.IT Tickets and pull requests are closing at the pace you agreed.3444
    QualityDoes the work hold up without a rework round?ERP Scripts pass user testing the first time and finance trusts the numbers.IT Code merges with the review comments you would give a peer.3344
    CommunicationDo you hear about a problem before it is a problem?ERP A slipped date arrives with a new date, before the old date.IT Blockers show up in the team channel that day, not at the next standup.4445
    Knowledge capturedCould someone else run it tomorrow?ERP An admin can run the integration from the runbook alone.IT Another engineer can deploy it from the readme.2334
    Team fitDo your own people work well with them?ERP Finance and the warehouse return their calls, and ask them back.IT Employees ask for their time, and their code reviews get answered.3455
    Average3.03.64.04.4
    Suggested callThe file suggests, you decide.ExtendExtendExtendConvert

    Sample entries for an ERP consultant, not a real contractor. Yours will differ. The average is the plain mean of the five scores, and the suggested call uses the three rules in the next section.

    Write the fact before the score. “Delivery 3” means nothing in six weeks. “Delivery 3, the month-end report slipped two days” means something, and the contractor can answer it.

    Then watch the knowledge captured row. It started lowest in the sample, and it should. But if it hasn’t reached 3 by day 90, you don’t have a process, you have a person, and the day that person rolls off is the day everything they know walks out the door with them.

    How Do You Decide to Extend, Convert or Roll Off?

    Three rules, applied to the last review. The shaded numbers are my defaults, so change them and keep the habit.

    Extend

    The last review averages 3.0 or better and the work is not done.

    • Write the new end date and the next review date on the form.
    • Pick the one score you want higher next time, and say which one out loud.
    • Tell your recruiter the new end date so the paperwork matches.

    Convert

    The last two reviews average 4.0 or better, nothing is under 3, and you have a seat for them after the project.

    • Talk to your KORE1 recruiter about conversion terms first.
    • Check the hours. KORE1 contractors convert at no fee after 1,040 hours, so a contractor a few weeks short can extend to the line.
    • Make the offer in writing, and set the start date with the contractor, not for them.

    Roll off

    One review averages under 2.5, or two reviews in a row average under 3.0.

    • Tell the contractor first, in person, before the team hears.
    • Set a last day that leaves room for the hand-off, and pull their access that day.
    • Tell your recruiter the same day and open the next search, because the median time from offer to start is 3 days (n=1,997).

    $0

    Converting after 1,040 hours. A KORE1 contractor who completes 1,040 hours, about 26 weeks at full time, can convert to your payroll at no additional charge from KORE1. Before that, talk to your recruiter about terms.

    20%

    Hiring direct instead. A KORE1 direct hire is 20% of base salary with a 60-day replacement guarantee, so $20,000 on a $100,000 base.

    It does happen. About 37.5% of KORE1 contract-to-hire placements convert to permanent employment (n=552). Most don’t. That’s fine. Extending and rolling off are normal outcomes, not failures, and the contract-to-hire conversion rates post shows how the number moves by role, if you want to see where your own seat sits before you decide.

    Ask KORE1 About Conversion Terms

    Have the contractor’s name, the hours to date and your decision date ready. Or read about contract-to-hire staffing first.

    37.5%

    of KORE1 contract-to-hire placements convert to permanent (n=552)

    116 days

    the median length of a KORE1 contract assignment (n=1,887)

    1,040

    hours of contract work before a KORE1 contractor converts at no fee

    3 days

    the median time from offer to start on a KORE1 contract (n=1,997)

    KORE1 engagement data for contract placements. Rates on this page are KORE1 bill rates for placements started 2023 to 2026, the records behind the Contract Rate Index 2026-Q4.

    What Does a Contractor Cost by the Time Conversion Is Free?

    Two seats from KORE1 placements, at the median bill rate for 26 weeks of 40 hours.

    • ERP consultant

      KORE1 placements, multi-state, n=15. Bill rates an hour.

      25th percentile
      $73
      Median
      $91
      75th percentile
      $123

      $94,400for 26 weeks of 40 hours at the median bill rate

    • Software engineer

      KORE1 placements, primarily Southern California, n=16. Bill rates an hour.

      25th percentile
      $91
      Median
      $105
      75th percentile
      $120

      $109,200for 26 weeks of 40 hours at the median bill rate

    That’s what the 1,040 hour line costs before it opens. It’s also why the reviews are worth the time. Skipping three conversations to save an hour each is a strange kind of saving when the seat bills this much and the decision at the end moves a headcount line, a budget and a team.

    Get a Bill Rate Quote

    Send the role, the metro and the weeks. Or browse the 2026 Contract Rate Card.

    Both cells are observed. Where KORE1 has fewer than five placements in a cell, the index models the rate from BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025, with a 24% employer burden and the bill range KORE1 observes. The full method is public.

    Department head in a charcoal cardigan listens with his head bowed while a contract ERP consultant in an olive overshirt explains something, each holding a white mug in an office kitchenette

    What Does the Manager Owe the Contractor?

    A fair review needs a fair manager. Picture the contractor who heard nothing for eight weeks, never got a straight answer about the access they asked for twice, and then got a 2 on communication in the day 60 review. That score belongs to both of you.

    “If you aren’t managing very well and you’re treating them kind of crappy as a manager, they’re going to… leave.”

    Devin Hornick, KORE1 partner

    You owe them

    • Write down what good looks like on day one, on one page, before the first review.
    • Give feedback inside a week of a problem. Never save it for the form.
    • Show the contractor their scores before you file them, and ask what you got wrong.
    • Unblock access, answers and decisions on the same timeline you expect the work on.
    • Introduce them early to the people who will inherit the work.
    • Tell them where they stand before the end date, not on it.

    Keeping a good contractor is mostly this list. The how to retain contractors post goes further, and the contractor access policy template covers the access items so a late login never becomes the reason for a low score on a review that was supposed to be about the work.

    Manager in a navy shirt sets a single blank sheet of paper into the middle of three empty grey letter trays on a wooden desk, a closed laptop and an orange mug beside her

    What a Contract Review Is Not

    It’s not a warranty claim, and that’s the one managers get wrong. Contract is built for speed and flexibility. You can scale a seat up or down quickly, and in exchange you give up the replacement promise that a direct hire carries, which is exactly why you review early instead of replacing late.

    A review is

    • A scheduled conversation at 30, 60 and 90 days, and again before renewal
    • Five scores, with one fact behind each
    • A written record you show the contractor
    • One decision at the end, to extend, convert or roll off

    A review is not

    • A replacement guarantee. A contract seat has none, and a KORE1 direct hire carries a 60-day one
    • A surprise. If a score is a shock, the feedback came too late
    • A substitute for feedback during the week
    • An employment file. Pay, hours and employment questions go through your KORE1 recruiter

    What a KORE1 contract does promise is short. Your contractor shows up on time and gets paid on Fridays, and after 1,040 hours they can convert at no fee. Everything else is the review.

    If a review turns into a dispute, call your recruiter. Don’t write a long email. That’s their job. When a contractor isn’t working out, the contractor not working out post covers the next steps, and the contractor handoff template covers the exit, including the access you pull and the notes you leave for whoever takes the work.

    Common Questions

    How often should you review a contractor?

    Four times. Review a contractor at 30, 60 and 90 days and again about two weeks before the end date, and finish each review with a decision to extend, convert or roll off. Skip day 60 on a short assignment.

    What should a contractor performance review cover?

    Five things, each scored 1 to 5 with one fact behind the score. Delivery, quality, communication, knowledge captured and team fit. Then answer one more question for yourself, which is whether the seat exists after the project.

    When should you convert a contractor to full time?

    When the last two reviews average 4.0 or better and the seat exists after the project ends. KORE1 contractors convert at no fee after 1,040 hours, and 37.5% of KORE1 contract-to-hire placements convert (n=552).

    How do you end a contract assignment without burning the relationship?

    Tell the contractor first, in person, then your recruiter, and set a last day that leaves time for a hand-off. Pull their access that day. A contract seat has no replacement guarantee, so open the next search the same week.

    Does KORE1 charge a fee to convert a contractor?

    Not after 1,040 hours. A KORE1 contractor who completes 1,040 hours, about 26 weeks at full time, can convert at no additional charge from KORE1. Short of that, ask your recruiter about terms before you say anything to the contractor, because a direct hire through KORE1 is 20% of base salary and the two paths are not priced the same.

    About the author

    Colin Boothe is CIO at Foretopia, where he leads ERP and business systems consulting. He has spent eight years implementing and optimizing NetSuite and integrated business tech stacks for mid-market wholesale, ecommerce and manufacturing companies. His author page lists everything he writes for KORE1.

    Hit Me Up Before the Renewal Date

    Tell us the role, the hours to date and your decision date. A KORE1 recruiter takes it from there.

    Send Us the Decision Date

    Not yet? Download the template first.